We Spent $5,000 Testing 7 Video Editing Services (Honest Results)

Share
Share
Share
Share
video editing services competitors

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

TLDR: Vidpros invested $5000 to test 7 different video editing services provided by their competitors. This provided valuable insights into the industry’s strengths and weaknesses. Key areas identified were the importance of good communication from any of these companies, quality, pricing, personalization, speed, and (a money-back or quality) guarantee. This information will be useful to VidPros to further improve their unique offering of fractional video editing.

The video editing world is booming. More people need us to make their videos seen, and our job market will grow 11% from 2020 to 2029. Video has become necessary and that’s why more and more people are searching for video editors analysis.

At Vidpros, we decided to put our money where our mouth is. We spent $5000 testing other editing services to see what our customers experience elsewhere. We wanted to analyze competitors to understand the good, the bad, and everything in between to serve our clients better.

This research didn’t just give us insights into our competitors; it reinforced our belief in our unique approach.

We do things differently here.

We offer personalized editing time, communicate clearly, and have flexible pricing for editing your raw footage. We use certain (professional) video editing tools to smooth the process and even provide a money-back guarantee. We’re upfront about what we can and can’t do, so everyone knows what to expect.

Methodology of this video editors’ analysis

We carefully chose our competitors for this review. We wanted to ensure we looked at a good mix of video editing services. Here’s how we picked them:

  • Service offerings and quality

  • Pricing and packages

  • Client communication and transparency

  • Customer reviews

  • Unique features

  • Industry reputation

  • Website usability

  • Unlimited video editing

We compiled our findings into a comprehensive competitor analysis report to track and monitor performance against our competitors.

For our $5000 experiment, we chose Tasty Edits, beCreatives, The Editor’s Connection, Vidchops, Increditors, and Flocksy.

We provided a ‘talking head’ style video to each competitor. This type of video is very common and thus enabled us to test the ability to cut up a video, make audio changes, and add graphics – making it easy for comparison purposes.

What Does “Unlimited Video Editing” Actually Mean?

“Unlimited” sounds wonderful, but it’s rarely ever unlimited.

Most times, it means you can submit as many projects as you’d like, but they will be done one at a time. So, yes, unlimited requests, but the output will be extremely limited.

And let’s face it, unless the service is totally AI-generated (which the below-mentioned aren’t), there will always be a human limitation. There’s only so much time in the day. There’s only so much quality the editors will allow.

We tested 17 different services touting the idea of unlimited video editing. They all basically had the same thing in common. And just so you know, while the limitation isn’t on the submissions, it IS on the speed at which the projects get done.

This is where the idea of fractional video editors, such as Vidpros’ model, makes a lot more sense.

Rather than touting the idea of unlimited, it’s more about the idea of dedicated editors. You get a certain number of editors dedicated to your projects.

Vidpros: The Baseline of this video editors’ analysis

Before going into our competitors’ analysis, we established a baseline by including Vidpros in our study. We created a typical client persona and submitted the same video request to our team, ensuring our editors were unaware of the test.

The entire process was designed to showcase our fractional video editing model in operation. A dedicated editor was allocated, as per our standard timeline and transparent pricing structure. Communication was handled through our unique chat platform and Frame.io, reinforcing our dedication to transparent and personalized communication.

The final product was consistent with our high-quality expectations and was in line with what we expected from the client. While we always aim high, it is worth noting that the production was good, hence a fair benchmark for comparison.

Below are the videos produced by Vidpros for the test. This is our standard editing approach and quality, hence a benchmark for the next comparisons with our competitors.

This self-assessment reinforced the strengths of our “fractional video editing” service and provided a valuable baseline for our competitive analysis.

  1. Dedicated editor time (for more personalized attention)

  2. Consistent quality output.

  3. Clear and direct (very important this one) communication channels.

  4. Transparent pricing without any hidden fees.

  5. Amazing turnaround times.

By including Vidpros in this analysis, we were able to gain valuable insights into our processes and compare them to our competitors in the industry. Obviously, this self-assessment helps us also to continually improve our services and our commitment to resolving common industry challenges.

Competitor Video Editor’s Analysis Report

TLDR

This table is a brief overview of the key aspects of each service, including Vidpros. It enables easy comparison between different video editing companies in different areas such as price, time taken, quality, communication, and their key strengths and weaknesses.

  • In this video editor’s analysis, we examined what products or services our competitors sell, including our offerings at Vidpros, to identify direct competitors and analyze their features and pricing.

This research helped us identify our main direct competitors and benchmark our success within the industry, positioning Vidpros among them.

  • We concentrated on the identification of the main competitors, ourselves included, to generate a comprehensive benchmarking report. We also assessed the marketing used by all the services, including Vidpros.

  • We checked out our competitors through a framework to know what we were good at and what we were poor at, as well as our strengths and weaknesses.

  • We assessed the audience’s response to the content and marketing approaches used by our competitors compared to the audience’s response to Vidpros.

Competitor analysis table

Tasty Edits

Tasty Edits stands out in the video editing market with its versatile service catering to various content types. Their strength lies in their user-friendly custom dashboard, direct communication with editors, and high-quality, professional work.

Tasty Edits makes use of video editing software to provide high-quality, professional output. Their pricing is competitive, ranging from $40 to $240 per video, and unlimited revisions are included.

However, our experience revealed some areas for improvement.

First, the revised drafts took up to 72 hours longer than expected. Additionally, the quality of the thumbnails has some room for improvement. However, the end product met our requirements and reflected the quality work that Tasty Edits has been known to provide.

In conclusion, Tasty Edits indeed offers the flexibility and professional quality service that it has been promising. This makes it a reliable service in the competitive video editing industry.

Though there is room for improvement in the speed of revision, the quality service and communication that Tasty Edits offers makes them a notable player in the video editing industry.

Here’s the final output video we received from Tasty Edits. This video reflects the quality work and style that they have been able to offer in our project.

beCreatives

beCreatives has earned itself a good reputation in video editing services with regards to social media. They provide dedicated video editors and communicate well via video calls.

They have two main pricing plans: the Scale plan ($899/month) and the Pro plan ($1999/month), which promise clients “unlimited revisions” and “fast turnaround times,” especially for the Pro plan.

Their business model excels in the quality of the videos they produce. They call it “professional grade” with “high production value,” and they use some of the best video editing software in the business.

However, there were some major issues in the service provided by beCreatives, as found from the experiences and feedback from the clients. For instance, despite the company’s claims of fast turnaround times for projects, there were major delays in the assignment of editors and completion of projects.

Some unknown charges and even staffing problems affected project timelines. Also, the company’s claims of quality issues for complex projects and unforeseen costs indicate a lack of consistency in the services provided.

Overall, beCreatives provides excellent results but needs improvement in terms of efficiency and client expectations. Despite the company’s claims of great communication and offering a money-back guarantee, there are issues with timely completion of projects and unforeseen costs.

For clients who prioritize video editing quality and social media friendliness AND are willing to take the risks of (possible) delays and additional fees, beCreatives remains an option worth considering.

Take a look at the video beCreatives produced for us.

The Editor’s Connection

The Editor’s Connection price range varies between $649 and $1,999 on a monthly basis. Its strength includes unlimited editing services, fast turnaround time, dedicated editors, and an efficient online communication system.

The client-centric policies of The Editor’s Connection include a 15-day money-back guarantee and unlimited revisions. These are two significant strengths for The Editor’s Connection.

However, our experience revealed several weaknesses. Firstly, there is a lack of personalization in their services. The website does not have photographs of their editors. This creates a problem in establishing a personal connection between the client and the editor.

We also noted inconsistencies in the editing quality…especially in following the more specific instructions for more complex projects. Although the company is great at basic video editing, it is not so great at specialized editing.

Their unlimited editing model and client-friendly policies make them an attractive option for straightforward editing needs.

Overall, The Editor’s Connection seems to be more geared towards clients who need dependable standard editing services rather than those who need special or highly technical or more complex video work.

Here is the completed video we got from The Editor’s Connection. It represents their standard editing work for a typical project.

Vidchops

Vidchops is a user-friendly, efficient video editing service focusing on speed and simplicity. Their strengths lie in quick turnaround times (1-2 days for initial edits, one day for revisions), dedicated editors, and an accessible online communication system.

Vidchops has a range of pricing plans, with the cost varying from $495 to $995 per month. This service is good at providing basic features related to video editing, including adding text, motion graphics, and transitions. This is especially useful in talking head videos where fast cuts and text overlays are required to keep the audience engaged.

The money-back guarantee and communication system are also good features.

However, Vidchops has certain drawbacks. The editing quality is good enough; however, it can be improved. Also, the advanced features like 3D effects or voice-overs need to be included in their editing software.

Our experience and user feedback indicate that the video editing quality varies across projects and there’s little room for creativity.

Vidchops offers users an excellent option if they are looking for a quick and easy editing experience. The platform is ideal for clients who want to make basic video editing (especially talking-head edits).

But, it may not be the best option for clients who want highly advanced video editing. The platform may not be able to meet the expectations of such clients in terms of the level of creativity involved.

Here’s what Vidchops delivered as our final edited video. It gives you an idea of their editing capabilities and style.

Increditors

The strengths of Increditors include the high quality of their work, which demonstrates their competence with text overlays, motion graphics, and high-end editing. This service excels in creating some good content with amazingly smooth transitions.

Their unique pricing model (which is based on a quiz) and client representatives are suitable for businesses with large budgets since they offer 2-3 revisions for each project and faster turnaround for the next projects.

But they need help in terms of communication and project management. Although they have mentioned project management tools, these tools have to be used better during the period of collaboration, which might have affected the tracking of the projects.

The primary means of contact was through email; however, more consistency was required. Their approach towards customer retention is questionable (as it appeared to be more passive in nature).

Increditors’ service, is not without operational issues in the aspects of communication and project management. The service is ideal for businesses looking for the best in editing quality, willing to deal with the potential issues in the process, and willing to pay the premium price.

The results are convincing, but you should be ready for some potential frustrations during the production stage.

Flocksy

Flocksy is another agency with a wide range of services including video editing, writing, and design. Their strengths include explicit communication, daily updates via a dedicated chat system, and a flexible pricing plan ranging from $499 to $1,695.

It includes the implementation of revision requests within 24 hours and they also use standard technology such as After Effects, Adobe Premiere Pro, and CapCut, that shows they have the technical skills to create great videos.

However, Flocksy’s weaknesses lie in meeting the initial turnaround time and creating high-quality work. For example, we noticed that Flocksy failed to meet the 72-hour mark, and the initial draft took a whole 6 days!

The absence of a video review tool with time markers made it difficult in terms of efficiency in the revision process. Although the quality of the first draft could have been better, it is not necessarily at its best.

Generally speaking, Flocksy appears to offer a great service for those in need of a one-stop shop for various creative requirements.

The middle-tier pricing option at $995 appears to be a great value for those in need of various creative services. Even though, it is important for the client to be prepared for likely delays and have a basic revision process.

Flocksy is best suited for those who value communication and flexibility over meeting deadlines and/or delivering high-quality work.

Here is the result of our project with Flocksy. The video showcases their approach to long-form video editing.

Video Husky

Video Husky prides itself on being a “done-for-you unlimited video editing” service with an emphasis on talking head videos. And that already says a lot about their market. They’re built for volume.

They’ve been around for about 6 years, which in this space is actually a solid run. Most similar services don’t last that long unless they’ve figured out a repeatable system. So clearly… something’s working.

But they don’t reveal their editor-to-client ratio, which, while perhaps not a major operational detail, is actually a very revealing figure about how your content will be treated once you become a client.

(Vidpros openly shares a 1:4 editor-to-client ratio, for example, and it is one of the top unlimited video editing services out there.)

Because let’s be honest, what does it mean to be an “unlimited” service? It means you get a queue-based system where all work is done one project at a time.

How are those projects done? They are lined up and completed one by one DEPENDING on availability and/or the workload that editors have to share in the background.

It’s a queue-based system.

If one editor has to deal with a lot of clients simultaneously, it might impact the speed, consistency, accuracy, and the editor’s familiarity with your voice over time.

And to be honest, many such services rely on the concept of turnaround time as the biggest selling factor. Well, it’s certainly easier to say “48-hour delivery” than to go into the details.

Turnaround time, however, isn’t the only factor.

And it surely doesn’t give you a clear idea of the number of revisions you might have to go through, the editor’s familiarity with your (brand’s) voice, or the number of back-and-forth communications it might take to get your final piece to where you want it.

Comparative Results

Our extensive analysis of the seven popular video editing services – Tasty Edits, beCreatives, The Editor’s Connection, Vidchops, Increditors, Flocksy and Video Husky – shows the variety in the services provided by these companies. Each has its advantages and difficulties.

Notable services provided by the companies include the flexibility of Tasty Edits, the social media capabilities of beCreatives, the unlimited support provided by The Editor’s Connection, the speedy services provided by Vidchops, the advanced use of graphics by Increditors, and the multi-service capabilities of Flocksy.

However, there are also some areas for improvement in each of the services, including pricing issues for high-end services like beCreatives and Increditors, quality issues for some services like Vidchops and Flocksy, issues in handling complex projects for some services, and communication issues for Increditors and Video Husky.

The price-quality ratio for these services differs greatly, with Tasty Edits being a great value proposition, while some services like beCreatives and Increditors charge high for high-end quality.

Eventually, this competitive service reminds us of the need to tie our service selection with our specific project needs, such as the need for special effects, quick turnaround times, or extensive creative services.

Head-to-Head Comparisons: Detailed analysis

We didn’t just review these services in isolation. We also compared them directly to see how they really work when you pit them against each other.

Because if you read the marketing materials for most video editing services, they all kind of sound the same. They all promise the same things: fast turnaround times, high-quality work, and some sort of “unlimited” or scalable approach to supporting your business.

But if you really compare them, the differences tend to add up in the small print. Things like the way they approach team structure, workload, consistency over time, and even the level of transparency they provide about the actual workload they can handle.

We also compared the way they work with different business models. Because not every business or creator has the same needs. Some need the flexibility of a video-by-video approach. Some need the predictability of a subscription model. Some need something in between.

  • Flocksy vs Vidpros — Flocksy offers an all-in-one creative subscription, while Vidpros focuses only on dedicated video editing with more consistency.

  • Vidchops vs Vidpros — Vidchops is a subscription-based editing service, but Vidpros leans into a more structured, fractional editing model.

  • Tasty Edits vs Vidpros — Tasty Edits charges per video content, while Vidpros offers a monthly plan with a dedicated editor.

  • Editor’s Connection vs Vidpros — Editor’s Connection uses the more conventional model of video editing services, whereas Vidpros uses the fractional model.

  • beCreatives vs Vidpros — beCreatives offers unlimited video editing services at a flat rate, whereas Vidpros offers dedicated video editing capacity.

  • Increditors vs Vidpros — Increditors is more of a high-end VFX and video editing house, whereas Vidpros offers consistent video editing services.

  • Video Husky vs Vidpros — Video Husky offers a “done-for-you unlimited” model, while Vidpros uses a fractional editing system with clearer workload balance.

Top Video Editing Companies in 2026

When you step back and look at the video editing companies in 2026, it’s not about “who’s the best,” it’s about “who’s the right fit for how you actually work.”

It’s not just freelancers versus agencies anymore. It’s a world of subscription services, premium studios, and fractional models that are quietly changing the way creators and business professionals think about video creation at scale.

For instance, Vidpros is taking the fractional approach in the sense that you are essentially buying editing process and time instead of the idea of “unlimited.”

On the other end, there’s Increditors, which position themselves as high-end video content editing companies where quality is more important than the number of edits. And then we have the middle ground like Motion Edits, who provide workflows that can be used for high outputs without being editor-centric.

The real difference, though, between any of these companies isn’t necessarily about price, speed, or any of those things. It’s about how predictable it is over time.

A lot of services sound pretty similar when it comes to talking about things like speed and unlimited requests. However, what it actually comes down to is things like:

  • How stable your editing team is

  • How well your editor actually gets your style

  • How your revisions work if something doesn’t quite hit the mark

  • How reliant your business is on how quickly the service can get through its own queue

Because if you think about it, video editing isn’t just a task. It’s a system inside your content workflow.

The Vidpros Video Editing Difference

Vidpros is distinguished from other video editing companies through its “Fractional Video Editing” service, offering clients access to monthly dedicated video editor time.

This process guarantees individualized service and quality, overcoming common video editing industry challenges like inconsistent quality and impersonalized service.

Our dedication to effective communication is reflected through our chat technology, which is specifically designed for the industry, as well as our use of Frame.io.

We pride ourselves on being transparent about our strengths and weaknesses.

Our pricing model is refreshingly simple and flexible, starting at just $1,000 per month for 2 hours of DAILY editor time.

At the moment, Vidpros is offering a $100 Professional Edits Package for 1 week. You can choose either 10 short-form edits or 1 long polished video, giving you a real feel for how our editing team works (so you don’t have to commit long term).

Lessons Learned

Our extensive analysis of the competition has revealed key areas that will shape our services and propel us to the forefront as the best solution for video editing.

Communication, quality and price consistency, and transparent pricing have been identified as vital elements for customer satisfaction. This has driven us to improve our systems and look for more flexible solutions.

It drives us to invest in editor training and workflow optimization.

Armed with these new findings, we are prepared to improve our services by prioritizing everything that matters for our clients.

Our goal is to transform these lessons into concrete improvements that establish Vidpros as the unequivocal go-to solution for top-tier video editing services.

FAQ

1. What is the best unlimited video editing service in 2026?

I don’t know if there is really a ‘best’ service for unlimited video editing. It all really depends on how you work. There are services that excel at quantity, while there are those that excel at consistency and a more hands-on approach. If you value the latter, then a fractional model like Vidpros can feel more stable compared to traditional ‘unlimited’ models.

2. How much do video editing services cost per month?

Based on our research, most services start from $40 per video OR $495-$4,000 per month, depending on the level of support, turnaround speed, and whether you get a dedicated editor or shared resources.

3. Is a dedicated editor better than a pool of editors?

Generally, yes. A dedicated editor usually means less going back and forth, more consistency, and a quicker grasp of your writing style. When using a shared pool, there’s often more ramp-up time every time a new editor works on your content.

4. What turnaround time should I expect?

The turnaround time for most projects is usually (realistically) 2-6 days. Some services even promise same-day delivery, but this is usually dependent on the queue load and the complexity of the project.

5. What’s the difference between “unlimited” and “fractional” video editing?

The difference between the two terms is usually in the number of requests you can submit. With “unlimited,” you can submit as many requests as you want, but they are done sequentially. With “fractional,” they focus on delivering you more OUTPUT.

Things to remember

We’ve done the research so you don’t have to. And when you compare different services side by side, the differences become pretty clear.

Some companies, like Video Husky, position themselves as “unlimited” editing platforms, while others such as Vidchops or Tasty Edits follow more traditional subscription or per-video models. Then you have high-end studios like Increditors that focus on premium, detailed work.

But here’s the real difference when you stack them up:

  • Many services rely on shared editors and queue-based systems.

  • “Unlimited” often comes with hidden workload limits.

  • Turnaround times can vary depending on internal capacity.

  • And consistency depends on how many editors touch your content.

Vidpros has a different model.

With our 1:4 editor-to-client ratio, you get your own dedicated editor instead of shared access. The fractional model provides actual editing capacity instead of the illusion of “unlimited” requests. And with our 24-hour turnaround and $1,000/month starting price, we remain competitive while keeping things manageable.

So when you compare services, the question isn’t just who edits your videos.

It’s how the editing actually gets done behind the scenes.

Not sure? Watch the demo or see the pricing.

About the Author

Mike

Michael Holmes is the founder and CEO of Vidpros, a trailblazer in video marketing solutions. Outside the office, Michael nurtures a growing community of professionals and shares his industry insights on the blog.

Find This Helpful?

Join the Vidpros community! Subscribe to our newsletter for cutting-edge strategies, expert social media insights, and exclusive offers to elevate your video production and marketing skills—delivered straight to your inbox.

*By submitting, you agree to receive emails from Vidpros and to our privacy policy.

Related Articles

Stay Inspired

Get in on the insider's loop with Vidpros! Sign up for our newsletter to snag exclusive insights, top-tier video marketing tactics, and special perks reserved for our community members.

By connecting with Vidpros, you’re opting into a stream of inspiration and our privacy policy.

A person with long black hair, wearing a maroon blazer and white shirt, sits cross-legged with a laptop on their lap, smiling at the camera. This content creator exudes confidence against the plain background.