How can creators dodge the pitfalls of equity deals in the creator economy?

pitfalls of equity deals in the creator economy

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

This article explores a growing trend in the creator economy: equity compensation in brand deals. Now, companies offer creators stakes and cash payments instead of just cash. This shift opens up new opportunities for long-term wealth building but comes with significant risks.

Discover the various types of creator equity compensation. We’ll explore the potential benefits, like sharing in a company’s growth, and the pitfalls to watch out for. Whether you’re considering an equity deal or want to understand your options better, this article will help you navigate this new terrain in the creator economy.

As we’ve seen, equity compensation offers creators both opportunities and risks. But to fully understand its place in the creator economy, we must examine the broader scene creators navigate today.

Understanding Equity Compensation for Creators

As a creator, you may be offered equity as compensation when working with companies. Equity represents partial ownership in the business, typically given in exchange for your content, audience, or other value you bring. This form of compensation is becoming increasingly common in the creator economy, especially when working with startups and growing businesses.

What is equity compensation? 

Equity usually comes in stock options or shares, often with a “vesting schedule” that requires you to stay with the company for a certain period before you can fully own or sell your shares.

Restricted stock units are a type of non-cash compensation that is unsecured and unfunded, and is considered nonqualified deferred compensation subject to specific IRS regulations.

Why do companies offer equity?

  • To attract talent when cash resources are limited through equity compensation plans.

  • To align the creator’s goals with the company’s long-term success.

  • To share potential future gains with contributors to the company’s growth.

Potential Benefits

  • Opportunity for significant financial gains if the company succeeds.

  • Deeper partnership and alignment with the brand or company.

  • Potential for long-term wealth building beyond immediate cash payments.

  • Potential tax benefits, especially with incentive stock options (ISOs), which can offer preferential long-term capital gains rates and avoid alternative minimum tax under certain conditions.

Key Risks

  • Company failure could render the equity worthless.

  • Equity must wait for a long time before being converted to cash.

  • Unpredictable value fluctuations.

Important Considerations

  • Equity value isn’t guaranteed and can increase or decrease over time based on the company’s stock price.

  • Liquidity events like acquisitions or IPOs are needed to cash out, but these are rare and often take years.

  • Only a tiny percentage of companies achieve the kind of success that makes equity valuable.

While equity offers the allure of potentially high returns, it’s crucial to understand that it’s a gamble on the company’s future success. As we go deeper into the specifics of equity deals and their implications for creators, remember that this form of compensation comes with significant opportunities and substantial risks.

The Creator Economy: Navigating Unpredictability, Fame, and Financial Success

The creator economy offers both exciting opportunities and significant challenges. As aspiring creators venture into this dynamic field, they must understand its intricacies and potential pitfalls.

Financial irregularity and income unpredictability

Creator income can fluctuate dramatically, contrasting sharply with traditional employment. Factors influencing earnings include:

  • Platform algorithms and policy changes.

  • Audience engagement levels.

  • Competitive landscape shifts.

  • Content visibility and promotion.

Market Saturation and Visibility Challenges

Gaining traction is increasingly difficult due to market saturation. Established creators often receive preferential treatment from platforms, creating substantial barriers for newcomers. Building a loyal following requires persistence and strategic content creation.

The Fleeting Nature of Fame

Equally swift declines can follow rapid rises to fame. Factors contributing to the loss of popularity include:

  • Controversies or public missteps.

  • Shifting audience interests.

  • Content stagnation or failure to evolve.

Notable examples of fluctuating creators’ fortunes

  • Logan Paul: Experienced significant reputational damage following a controversial video.

  • Tana Mongeau: Audience interest waned due to perceived content monotony.

  • Lele Pons: Successfully transitioned between platforms but needed help maintaining audience engagement.

Platform dependence and its risks

Many creators rely heavily on a few major platforms, such as YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram. Changes in platform policies or algorithms can significantly impact a creator’s business model, highlighting the importance of diversification.

Long-term career viability and job security

Due to the industry’s budding and evolving nature, the sustainability of creator careers remains to be determined. Only a small percentage of creators establish enduring, profitable businesses. The profession needs more stability and benefits associated with traditional employment, with unpredictable income and career trajectories. Understanding how equity compensation works can be a financial tool to help manage these challenges.

Success Predictability

Forecasting long-term success in the creator economy is challenging for creators, brands, and investors alike. The industry’s rapid evolution makes it difficult to determine which content or creators will maintain long-term relevance and impact. 

Strategies for Success

  • Consistently produce high-quality, engaging content (consider hiring Vidpros if you need high-quality video editing for your video content).
  • Adapt to platform and audience preference shifts.
  • Develop business sense and diversify revenue streams.
  • Cultivate strong audience relationships.
  • Address challenges professionally and learn from setbacks.
  • Focus on building a sustainable career rather than pursuing short-term fame.

The first step in the creator economy is to achieve initial fame or success. The true challenge lies in maintaining relevance, adapting to change, and establishing a lasting career beyond fleeting popularity.

While the field offers numerous opportunities for success, it also presents significant risks, necessitating constant adaptation and evolution. Creators must balance their creative passion while developing a sustainable business model as they navigate changes.

Given these challenges in the creator economy, it’s crucial to consider various compensation models carefully. Let’s explore the different options available to creators, including equity-based arrangements.

Creator Compensation: Evaluating risk and reward structures

As creators navigate partnership and compensation opportunities, they encounter various models with distinct advantages and potential drawbacks. Consider the following options:

Upfront Cash Compensation

  • Immediate remuneration for services rendered.

  • Examples: Sponsorships and paid collaborations.

  • Advantages: Instant liquidity, minimal long-term risk.

  • Disadvantages: Potential opportunity cost if the partnering entity experiences significant growth.

Equity-Based Compensation and Restricted Stock Units

  • Acquisition of company shares instead of or in addition to monetary payment.

  • Advantages: Potential for substantial returns if the company succeeds.

  • Disadvantages: High risk; the possibility of share devaluation.

Revenue-Sharing Agreements

  • The compensation is determined based on a percentage of the revenue generated.

  • Examples are the YouTube monetization program and the Twitch partnership arrangements.

  • Advantages: Direct correlation between content performance and earnings.

  • Disadvantages: Income unpredictability.

Hybrid Compensation Models

  • Combination of upfront payment and equity allocation.

  • Example: Gumroad’s creator partnership structure.

  • Advantages: Balances immediate income with potential future gains.

  • Disadvantages: Retains some level of risk.

Alternative Monetization Strategies

  • Crowdfunding, course creation, merchandise sales, and premium content offerings are options.

  • Advantages: Greater autonomy and direct audience engagement.

  • Disadvantages: Requires management of multiple revenue streams.

Critical Considerations for Equity Arrangements

  • Long-term value proposition of company ownership.

  • Equity percentage and current valuation.

  • Potential for equity dilution.

  • Liquidity events and timelines.

  • Impact on Creative Autonomy.

  • Company’s financial performance and sustainability.

  • Availability of alternative compensation structures.

Important Factors to Evaluate

  • Income Diversification: Mitigate risk by maintaining multiple revenue streams.

  • Risk Assessment: Recognize the high failure rate of startups and the potential for equity devaluation.

  • Strategic Alignment: Ensure compatibility with long-term career objectives.

  • Professional Consultation: Seek legal and financial advice for complex arrangements.

  • Creative Independence: Prioritize maintaining artistic freedom.

Scenarios Favoring Equity Compensation

  • High-profile creators with significant growth potential.

  • Creators developing scalable media enterprises.

  • Precise alignment between the creator’s long-term strategy and company objectives.

  • Creators possessing business sense beneficial to company growth.

It is important to evaluate compensation structures, weighing potential benefits against concessions carefully. Ensure alignment with personal and professional goals, and strive for a diversified income portfolio rather than relying on a single revenue stream.

While we’ve touched on some of the risks associated with equity compensation, it’s essential to dig deeper into these potential pitfalls, especially when dealing with startups and tech companies.

Risks Associated with Equity Deals for Creators

When considering equity as part of a compensation package, creators must be aware of the significant risks involved, mainly when dealing with startups and tech companies like SaaS (Software as a Service) firms.

High Failure Rates

The stark reality is that most startups fail. Approximately 90% of startups don’t survive beyond their first year, and in the tech sector, which includes many SaaS companies, the failure rate is less than 60%. When you accept equity, you’re essentially betting on a company that statistically has a high chance of failing.

Extended Timelines

Even if a company survives, realizing any value from equity typically requires a minimum of 10 years. This timeline often includes:

  • 6-18 months for securing initial investment.

  • 4-6 years for company growth.

  • 4-6 years for executing an exit strategy (acquisition or IPO).

  • Potentially 1-2+ years for company dissolution if unsuccessful.

Your equity may be non-liquid during this extended period, meaning you can’t easily convert it to cash.

Equity Value Volatility

The value of your equity can fluctuate dramatically over time, influenced by factors such as:

  • Company performance

  • Investment climate

  • Market competition

  • Management effectiveness

  • Investor sentiment

Even initially successful companies can face significant challenges. For example, Groupon’s popularity and value plummeted after its initial success, resulting in substantial losses for equity holders.

Common Causes of Failure

Understanding why startups fail can help you assess the risks. Common reasons include:

  • Misalignment with market needs.

  • Insufficient capital.

  • Ineffective marketing strategies.

  • Internal team conflicts.

  • Inability to compete effectively.

Opportunity Cost

You may miss other opportunities while waiting for equity to appreciate. The time and potential earnings invested are lost, and there’s no return guarantee even after an extended period.

Mitigation Strategies

To navigate these risks, consider the following:

  • Don’t rely solely on equity compensation; ensure you receive cash payments.

  • Conduct thorough due diligence on the company before accepting equity.

  • Evaluate your tolerance for extended investment periods.

  • Assess your financial capacity to have a portion of compensation non-liquid for an extended period.

  • Diversify your income streams to mitigate risk.

  • Look closely at the company’s product, market fit, business plan, and leadership team.

While equity deals offer the potential for significant returns, they carry substantial risks. For many creators, focusing on building a sustainable business model with diverse revenue streams may provide more immediate and reliable financial stability than speculating on potential long-term equity appreciation. 

Remember, taking equity, especially in a startup, is similar to buying a lottery ticket – there’s a chance you could win big, but it’s much more likely you’ll lose your investment. Be intelligent and cautious, and avoid putting all your eggs in one basket.

Capping Off

Equity compensation offers creators exciting opportunities for wealth building, but it comes with significant risks. From high startup failure rates to extended timelines for realizing value, creators must carefully weigh the potential rewards against the considerable uncertainties. 

While equity deals can be enticing, it’s crucial to maintain a balanced approach to compensation. Consider diversifying your income streams and ensuring a stable cash flow alongside any equity arrangements. 

The key to success in the creator economy lies in making informed decisions that balance the allure of potential big wins with the need for financial security and sustainable career growth.


About the Author

Mylene Dela Cena

Mylene is a versatile freelance content writer specializing in Video Editing, B2B SaaS, and Marketing brands. When she's not busy writing for clients, you can find her on LinkedIn, where she shares industry insights and connects with other professionals.

Find This Helpful?

Join the Vidpros community! Subscribe to our newsletter for cutting-edge strategies, expert social media insights, and exclusive offers to elevate your video production and marketing skills—delivered straight to your inbox.

*By submitting, you agree to receive emails from Vidpros and to our privacy policy.

Related Articles

Stay Inspired

Get in on the insider's loop with Vidpros! Sign up for our newsletter to snag exclusive insights, top-tier video marketing tactics, and special perks reserved for our community members.

By connecting with Vidpros, you’re opting into a stream of inspiration and our privacy policy.

Visit Vidpros at the NABShow Conference!

April 13th-17th at Las Vegas Convention Center