Instructional Video Production When Your Expert Isn’t an Actor

Share
Share
Share
Share
Instructional Video Production When Your Expert Isn't an Actor

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

The majority of instructional designers we work with at Vidpros understand the pedagogy. They have developed the learning objectives, used Bloom’s taxonomy to map the content and have storyboarded the assessments. However, once they get to the point of setting up a camera, interviewing a subject matter expert who has never been taped, and taking ninety minutes of rambling and turning it into a seven minute piece, that is what this guide will help you with. It is a working playbook for instructional video development that was designed for instructional designers and media professionals that are familiar with the end results from the learner perspective. When I say “instructional video” I am referring to any type of premeditated video-based asset that is created with specific educational goals in mind, regardless if it is part of a course shell, LMS playlist or a corporate training portal.

If your company is creating courses and coaching through video, these online course video production & educational video production guidelines were designed to be used in that manner. The guide below is intended for Learning Development (L&D) Teams, Instructional Design Teams, working with Subject Matter Experts (SME’s), Faculty and Staff.

Defining Educational Video Production: Core Formats for Corporate Video Production and Learning Videos

Instructional Video Production When Your Expert Isn't an Actor - figure 1

There are five types of formats that cover most of what instructional design teams create.

The recorded faculty lecture is one of the workhorses of instructional video. An SME talks directly to camera (with slides possibly appearing behind them) and then the resulting video becomes the core element of an asynchronous course. eCampus Ontario indicates the recommended duration of such recordings is typically 5 to 7 minutes and an average version of a 2-minutes recording would contain approximately 360 words of script.

A screencast is simply software training, nothing more. The designer records their computer screen while talking over top of it and the students view the designer clicking through a series of steps. In their 5-step guide to creating your own instructional videos, Edutopia states that the best screencasts use visual aids to draw attention to key elements of what is being shown on the screen and limit on-screen text. Examples include: a nursing educator demonstrating how to document patient information using Electronic Health Records (EHRs); a payroll manager illustrating how to complete tasks within Workday; a technologist teaching faculty members how to grade assignments using Canvas, etc.

Scenario videos are short dramatizations of real-world scenarios. This can be an actor portraying a doctor during a medical interview that doesn’t go well, an employee/customer service representative dealing with a difficult customer or two co-workers having an argument in the workplace. Students watch and try to figure out what happens next. While often the most expensive to produce well, they are also among the most impactful when done correctly.

Demonstrations show a student completing a physical process. For example: how to perform a weld, how to prepare certain ingredients in a kitchen, or how to properly calibrate scientific laboratory equipment. The positioning of the cameras is extremely important in this format since students must be able to clearly see the actions of the SME.

Lab walkthrough videos are hybrids, they combine demonstrations with mini lectures. These videos are filmed in the same location as the class being taught. Manchester created a storyboarding guide for video projects. Although this guide does not specifically categorize lab walkthrough videos, they did so because of potential location-specific constraints (such as sound/lighting/safety).

Know which of these five formats you are producing before you start writing any shots.

Executing corporate training video production at an enterprise standard demands an agile, repeatable video production process. When enterprise L&D leads invest in high quality video production and partner with professional video production services, they guarantee that every single video project captures nuanced subject matter accurately. Moving away from dry talking-head monologues toward dynamic learning video production and polished professional video production ensures that every course module maintains learner retention across complex enterprise curricula.

Strategic Elearning Video Production: Aligning Educational Content with Measurable Learning Outcomes

Plan first, format second. Always.

One of the biggest mistakes teams encounter is selecting a format prior to defining what the learner has to accomplish after viewing. Teams select “we’ll create a screencast,” and then retro-fit the objectives to match the format. eCampus Ontario states it clearly, define your learning objectives from the learner’s point of view before proceeding with any other steps.

Test your objectives. Say the objective out loud, using “after this video, a learner will be able to…”. If the verb used in the objective is “describe,” “list” or “explain,” a recorded lecture or animated explainer is suitable. If the verb is “perform,” “demonstrate,” or “operate,” you should consider creating a screencast or providing a live demonstration. If the verb is “decide,” “evaluate” or “select,” you are likely to require a scenario video (with possible branching).

Learning objective

Best instructional video type

Typical length

Describe / explain a concept

Recorded lecture or animated explainer

5 to 7 minutes

List or summarize steps

Screencast with voice-over

3 to 6 minutes

Perform or operate equipment

Demonstration (camera on the SME’s hands)

4 to 8 minutes

Navigate software or a system

Screencast walkthrough

4 to 7 minutes

Decide, evaluate, or choose

Scenario video, with or without branching

3 to 6 minutes per branch

Apply a procedure in a physical setting

Lab walkthrough (demo + mini-lecture on location)

6 to 10 minutes

Upon identifying the objective, evaluate all inputs. Who is your subject matter expert (SME)? Are there existing pieces of footage and/or graphic elements available? Is someone delaying the project due to obtaining either legal department approval or approvals within your own department? Chairs may need to approve a faculty member’s recorded lectures. SME, legal, and brand approvals are required for compliance-based training. Create your schedule based upon the longest approval cycle, not the quickest production day.

The primary objective when creating elearning videos for a diverse target audience is delivering high quality videos that translate directly into operational competence. Whether designing compliance refreshers or technical software walk-throughs, building an institutional framework for training video production requires mapping every scene to specific performance rubrics before filming starts.

A pre-production check-list for most potential issues:

  • A learning objective defined in learner facing terms, with a specific verb.
  • The format was selected based upon the objective.
  • SME was briefed & scheduled with a buffer for re-shooting.
  • Talent release signed; FERPA compliant releases were signed by participants who appeared in the video and/or their learner work.
  • Captions, transcripts, & color contrast meet WCAG 2.1 AA standards. Additionally federally funded institutions must comply with ADA Section 508 regulations.
  • All music & stock footage licensing completed prior to delivery of the rough cut.

If you regularly produce videos, document this as a training video production intake form.

Scripting for Active Learning: Storyboarding Live-Action and Animated Video Modules

Instructional Video Production When Your Expert Isn't an Actor - figure 2

All of the referenced storyboard materials are based on the assumption that there is a complete script available, and that the SME will simply read through it. In reality this is rare, so the best way to proceed is to create a shot list from the interview questions: write out the beats as if you were the SME, take each beat and turn it into a question you would be asking them during the video interview, record the video interview, and build your script using what they actually say. We walk through the full process in How To Make A Training Video.

Setting up the classroom space or recording area

You don’t need a studio to produce a high-quality video. But you will want to control the lighting on the SME’s face, place a microphone directly under the SME’s chin (or very near), and find a background that does not include any windows or a fluorescent ceiling. Audio is much more important than image quality, so even a low cost camera with a great lavalier microphone will be better than an expensive camera with poor audio. We go deeper on setup in Training Video Production.

Producing Instructional Videos: Working With Subject Matter Experts On Camera vs Voice-Over Treatment

One of the largest decisions you’ll make regarding producing instructional video content involves determining whether your subject matter expert (SME) appears on camera or simply provides voice-over treatment.

Using on-camera treatments is ideal when the SME is willing to appear on-camera, the institution desires to associate the SME with the video content (i.e., faculty branding, executive messaging, etc.), and the overall content format lends itself well to a live person being visible during the delivery of the content.

Voice-over treatments are best utilized when the SME is camera shy, the majority of the video includes screen shots or other images, and/or the final product will be distributed throughout multiple courses. Additionally, voice-over recordings are generally quicker to produce. A typical 10-minute voice-over recording session can usually be completed in about 30 minutes; while an average on-camera treatment can take anywhere from 90 minutes to 2 hours.

Several pre-production strategies help streamline the process when using on-camera SMEs. Inform the SME that there are no rules governing restarts and that they can stop and begin again at any time. Avoid utilizing teleprompters unless the SME is familiar with them. Typically film both the technical aspect of the response followed by the non-technical explanation (the “warm-up”). Also always film additional 30 seconds of silent room tone prior to wrapping each session.

When creating voice-over treatments, ensure that you record the SME in either a small carpeted room or a closet with hanging clothing. Handheld digital recorders (such as Zoom H5, Zoom F3) provide significantly better results than recording via laptop speakers. Encourage the SME to stand while recording; this helps engage the diaphragm resulting in a more present sounding read.

Video creation tools

The majority of teams use the software that their institution has already licensed. If you’re going to teach something with lots of screens, you’ll probably use a screencasting tool. For everything else where you might want to edit together pieces of footage (e.g., interviews) and put them in order, you can use full-fledged editing software. Finally, if you plan to deliver your videos inside of an LMS (Learning Management System) you’ll want to choose a hosting platform that allows for seamless integration. Interactive elements such as branching, hot spots, and knowledge checks require specialized interactive video platforms. We cover the options in more depth in Training Video Software.

Post-production craft: Cuts, Captions, B-Roll, Call-outs, Chapter Markers

Post-production is where instructional videos either succeed or fail. Here’s a working process for producing a 7-minute video, in order:

Rough cut: take all the best takes from the interviews, place them into script order, and remove all filler at the beginning and end of the answers. The rough cut will usually run 20 to 40 percent longer than the final.

Pacing pass: remove “uhms” individually, but don’t go crazy. Natural speakers pause occasionally. Removing all of them will create that over-edited feeling that tells viewers they’re watching a corporate video.

B-roll layer: add visual aids above the SME’s voice. When she says “the pH meter,” show the pH meter. When she says “this could be a problem if learners skip step three,” show a graphic of step three. According to the Just Ask Publications guide on recording and using instructional videos, there should be a visual aid to accompany every key concept.

Call-outs: add the SME’s name and title as lower third titles, use consistent typology for key terms, and number steps for procedural videos. Don’t put so much text on the screen that it becomes difficult to read. As noted by Edutopia, the best instructional videos minimize on-screen text.

Always include captions. WCAG 2.1 AA requires that captions are synchronized; Section 508 requires that captions are also synchronized for federally funded institutions. Auto-generated captions provided by YouTube, Descript, or Otter typically average around 90 to 95% accurate when transcribing clean English audio. For 100% accuracy, apply a human review to the remaining 5 to 10%. A human review typically takes no more than 15 minutes per 10 minutes of video.

If the video exceeds four minutes in length, consider adding chapter marks. YouTube will read these from timed descriptions, while most Learning Management System players can manually enter them.

Once completed, add a LUT to ensure color consistency across all frames, normalize the audio level to -16 LUFS, and set the background music bed at -22 to -24 dB below the speaker. Finally, export the file as 1080p H.264 at 8 to 10 Mbps. Once exported, check the entire video at full resolution prior to publishing.

Common Instructional Video Mistakes To Avoid

Reading from the Script Word for Word: the SME sounds unnatural, her energy decreases rapidly, and learners tune out within two minutes. Instead, use the Shot List Interview method.

Editing Too Tight: all “uhms” are removed and the SME sounds like a robot. Leave some natural texture.

Not including Captions and Transcripts: both are required for accessibility purposes. Additionally, providing transcripts provides a search advantage on publicly accessible websites.

Using Any Music Available on Your Laptop: only license or original music should be used. Services such as Artlist ($16/month), Musicbed ($25/month), and Epidemic Sound ($16/month) offer affordable options.

Including Identifiable Learners or Student Work Without Releasing Their Images: FERPA still applies even if you intend to positively portray their images. Obtain their image releases prior to capturing their video.

Engineering the First Project Too Much: a team’s first video doesn’t require complex features such as branching scenarios, customized animation for lower thirds, or a custom introduction. Deliver simply and allow time for feedback and iteration.

Failing to Preview in the LMS: the video appears differently in Canvas, Blackboard, Cornerstone than it did in your preferred editing application. Test your video before launching.

Scaling Corporate Training Video Production: Aligning Corporate Training with Core Business Goals

There are several breakpoints when in-house production stops scaling. These breakpoints occur through:

Throughput Stalls: the team delivers two videos per month and now wants to produce eight. The scripts and SMEs are available; however, the editing is now the constraint.

Quality Plateaus: competent screencasts are produced; however, the strategic asset (i.e., flagship course, recruitment video, certification program) is not polished enough by the team.

Turn-Around Pressure: due to updated subject matter, 30 existing videos need to be re-cut in six weeks. The team can either edit new content or maintain its current library of assets; not both.

At this point, it is common for outsourced post-production to win based on pure mathematics alone. A video producer who regularly edits instructional video receives your hour-long faculty interview in less time than a media specialist juggling twelve other projects for editing new content versus maintaining a library of existing content; the cost-based economics favor the producer when you are delivering more than four to six finished videos per month.

What to look for:

An education and L&D portfolio (not just marketing video; pacing assumptions vary)

Familiarity with LMS export specs & accessibility requirements

Defined two round revision cycle

Comfort with raw unscripted SME interview footage

Our initial intake question is always: what does a learner need to do after he/she watches this? We then develop everything else from there. The spokes on How To Make A Training Video and E-Learning Video Production Specs outline what is expected as far as deliverables are concerned; Lecture Capture Workflows outlines how Higher Ed institutions can implement lecture capture workflow.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Instructional Video Production

How long should an instructional video be? Approximately five to seven minutes for each single concept. eCampus Ontario suggests that average length, stating that a two-minute video typically equates to approximately 360 words of written script.

What is the difference between an instructional video and training video? Instructional videos are commonly used in K-12 and higher education settings; while training videos are often utilized by corporate learning & development departments. While there may be differences in production methods, they generally follow the same principles.

Do I need to use a studio? No. Ninety percent of the work can be done using a controlled office or classroom setting with a single soft light source, one lavalier microphone and a background that is free from distractions.

How do I caption an instructional video? Auto-generate captions through the use of YouTube, Descript or Otter; and then edit those captions manually to ensure accuracy. Once edited, export them into either SRT or VTT format and import them into your LMS for use.

How much does instructional video production cost? If outsourcing, expect to pay anywhere from $1,500 to $5,000 depending upon complexity for a completed 7 minute instructional video; and significantly more if utilizing high levels of animation and/or multiple scenarios. As you begin to utilize subscription-based models, the per-video cost drops off rapidly at-scale.

Are there AI tools that can help me produce my own videos? Yes. They can help. AI can auto-generate captions, provide a preliminary transcription of audio files, remove filler words from initial transcriptions and more. However, at present time AI cannot produce videos at the level of an experienced professional when it comes to voice cloning, generating B-roll imagery and writing scripts for instructional videos.

If your organization has subject matter experts ready to go, rough drafts of scripts created and production-ready but post-production is creating bottlenecks, book a Vidpros consult or please submit a sample of your raw footage. We’ll have our editors complete the first asset so that we can demonstrate how our process compares to what you’ve been able to accomplish in-house prior to making any decisions.

Vidpros $100 first-week trial: 10 hours of professional video editing

About the Author

Mike

Michael Holmes is the founder and CEO of Vidpros, a trailblazer in video marketing solutions. Outside the office, Michael nurtures a growing community of professionals and shares his industry insights on the blog.

Find This Helpful?

Join the Vidpros community! Subscribe to our newsletter for cutting-edge strategies, expert social media insights, and exclusive offers to elevate your video production and marketing skills—delivered straight to your inbox.

*By submitting, you agree to receive emails from Vidpros and to our privacy policy.

Related Articles

Stay Inspired

Get in on the insider's loop with Vidpros! Sign up for our newsletter to snag exclusive insights, top-tier video marketing tactics, and special perks reserved for our community members.

By connecting with Vidpros, you’re opting into a stream of inspiration and our privacy policy.

A person with long black hair, wearing a maroon blazer and white shirt, sits cross-legged with a laptop on their lap, smiling at the camera. This content creator exudes confidence against the plain background.